2005
(Positions 3-6 not definite)
1. AK Ballers
2. The Warriors
3. Brokeback Yankes
4. Death Valli
5. GreenLeafs
6. Wen Kroy Stem
7. Suicidal Army
8. DJ Bildo Rippin IT UP
2006
Darryl Kile's Breakout Year
| Death Valli | 12 - 8 - 2 |
| Suicidal Army | 9 - 8 - 5 |
| HardenLong | 9 - 9 - 4 |
| AK Ballers | 8 - 14 - 0 |
| Brokeback Yankees | 4 - 14 - 4 |
Ken Caminiti Fan Club
| DJ Bildo |
14 - 6 - 2 |
| The Warriors |
13 - 7 - 2 |
| Green Leafs | 11 - 8 - 3 |
| weN kroY steM | 11 - 8 - 3 |
| Beavis | 4 - 13 - 5 |
2007
Corey Lidle Fan Club
| DJ Bildo |
17 - 5 - 1 |
| Green Leafs |
11 - 9 - 3 |
| The Warriors |
11 - 9 - 3
|
| Nig Guy |
7 - 12 - 4 |
| Beavis |
7 - 15 - 1 |
Jason Grimsley's Breakout Year
| Suicidal Army |
14 - 9 - 0 |
| Death Valli |
13 - 9 - 1 |
| Harden Long |
11 - 10 - 2
|
| Brokeback Yankees |
9 - 13 -1 |
| AK Ballers |
7 - 16 - 0
|
2008
Josh Hancock's Driving School
| Brokeback Yankees |
16 - 7 - 0 |
| The Warriors |
12 - 10 - 1 |
| Death Valli |
11 - 10 - 2
|
| Green Leafs |
9 - 14 - 0 |
| Nig Guy |
4 - 18 - 1 |
McNamee's Health Club
| DJ Bildo |
14 - 9 - 0 |
| Blazzin Alcoholics |
13 - 9 - 1 |
| Suicidal Army |
12 - 10 - 1
|
| Harden Long |
12 - 11 - 0 |
| AK Ballers |
9 - 14 - 0
|
2009
All ties were removed prior to start of season. A 5X5 scoring system was implemented with IP being used as a tiebreaker.
Jim Leyritz's HR trot to prison
| Blazzin Alcoholics |
13 - 10 |
| Sweet Chien Music |
12 - 11 |
| Death Valli |
11 - 12
|
| HardenLong |
10 - 13 |
| Suicidal Army |
8 - 15 |
Roberto Alomar's AIDs Test
| Green Leafs |
17 - 6 |
| DJ Bildo |
14 - 9 |
| The Warriors |
11 - 12
|
| AK Ballers |
10 - 13 |
| Brokeback Yankeess |
9 - 14
|
|